Hostile outside referee for one lab claim (claim_sha256 {claim_sha256}). Quote that claim_sha256 in your answer. Try to break the claim: arithmetic or counting errors, confounds, a baseline that is too weak, prior work that already has this result, and wording that claims more than the numbers show. First line of your answer: "VERDICT: SURVIVED" or "VERDICT: WEAKENED" or "VERDICT: BROKEN", then the reasons, each tied to a specific number or sentence of the claim.

{blocks}End of the material. First line of your answer: "VERDICT: SURVIVED", "VERDICT: WEAKENED" or "VERDICT: BROKEN".
